Submit Alternative Response Technology Ideas for the Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill

 

   Oil Spill Ideas
Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
  Ralph C. Whitley - Backflow Prevention - Ideas and Responses to the Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill Page 1 2 3 4 5
Brad Wehde BP Deepwater Horizon Catastrophe Solutions to Stop the Flow of Oil into the Gulf of Mexico
What Actually Happened with Transocean Deepwater Horizon Explosion
Oil Spill Cleanup Jobs
   Share/Bookmark
   
 

 

   
 

    Alternative Response Technology for Capping the Deepwater Horizon Oil Well & for Oil Spill Cleanup

Put a balloon on the end of a pipe insert it into the well then inflate the balloon with air or fluid until it seals off the oil flow.   This is similar to the balloon angioplasty used to open clogged arteries except the balloon would be made of heavy rubber and the balloon would remain inflated until the well is properly capped.   This is also the technology used by plumbers to open drains (pipe snake). The balloon and pipe could probably be inserted by underwater robots.

D Jimison
Daniel.Jimison@drakesoftware.com


Hello , here's my solution.

Before deployment of the umbrella-stent inside riser, if deemed necessary because insufficient trust in the barbs, the insertion pipe through which then the concrete later will be pumped might be welded to the end of the riser.

Andrej Radoš,  Läkare, Lääkäri, M.D., Psychiatrist
Långbrokajen 7-9 B 87
00530 Helsingfors
FINLAND
+358405735618
andrej.rados@welho.com
andrej.rados@hus.fi
arrados@gmail.com


I propose putting an umbrella over the leak.  The oil would rise into the umbrella.  It could be situated high enough up so the velocity of the leak has dissipated.  Since the oil rises it would be trapped by the umbrella.  The oil could then be pumped into tankers.

This would allow the oil to be captured until the well can actually be capped.  This would limit the disaster and take the panic mode out of the current proposals.

Later
Jim


What about making a 5500 ft silo type container out of either reinforced concrete or some sort of strong steel then move it out by barges lowered and guided by subs (manned and unmanned) and could use barges to push such structure upright. Towards the top of this structure there could be a relief valve installed so that oil tankers can load. As far as the clean up we could come up with something that can be installed on a set amount of tankers that can pump the contaminated seawater on board filter the oil out and store the oil on board and pump clean water back into the ocean.
 
Thank You
Charles Pittman
P.S. If someone could help me get to the gulf region I would love to help in any way possible. Please send email.
...For the top kill and junk shot, I would consider
A ? Tonnage Steel Wedge,,,,and drop it on the end of the 2 foot pipe laying on the ocean floor to Crimp that end.........even dropping it front of the pipe. if crimping it would cause damage to pipe further up would create a back pressure.
I wouldn't think anything will work until that pipe is crimped or the flow is dramatically reduced, also using,,,
? tonnage tapered plugs and drop in the top of the BOP would help
 
Thx
 
Dan Huckins
Retired QA Mgr 20 yrs, Military,

A pipe patch can be built and deployed quickly the patch will never stop all the leaking oil but it may stop enough to allow the hydraulic mud to accumulate this drawing is simplistic but it does show the elements.


Jeff Nettekoven
Neenah, WI
jnettekoven@new.rr.com
920-751-3895

containment dome, steel, brass, lead ,rubber.
No additional equipment should be needed on site.
an engineer to study the fluid dynamics and to evaluate if this device would conform to the damaged pipe.

THIS POSSIBLE SOLUTION WOULD BE TO STOP THE OIL LEAK. Build a platform with 4 legs that would sink into the ocean floor for stability. It would look similar to a giant end table. On the bottom of the platform would be a a cone that could be inserted into the broken pipe. The cone would be similar in shape to the sharpened end of a pencil. It would be made of brass, lead, or steel etc. It could end up with straight edges, have o rings attached or whatever engineers feel would seal the best. On the top of this table would be enough weight, lead etc to hold the table in place and overcome the pressure of the oil and conform the cone for a good seal. If the pipe were cut to a clean edge this table could possibly just have a flat bottom with an appropriate metal or rubber seal. I am not exactly sure of how damaged the pipe is as the picture is not real clear, which is why the pipe may have to be cut. This device could be tested on the surface using water or a fluid or oil with similar pressure. It also may be possible to install the cone or flat bottom in the containment dome that has already been built. I hope this may help, I am not an engineer but feel this or a similar idea may stop the leak, especially if the pipe had a clean edge. Also if the pipe is bent or crushed a steel or hardened steel cone may conform it back to round with enough pressure and seal the leak. Thank you for your time, I hope this may help.


Idea for containment of oil spill: (Operation ROVPDC) or (Remote Operational Vehicle Probe & Drogue Containment):

If it were possible to retro-fit an (ROV) using the same principle ideas of that used in the refueling of jets by a device known as the (Probe & Drogue Fuel System). Thus containing or re-directing the flow of leaking oil too bide time. Think of the (ROV) as if it was a jet needing fuel but instead it would be sucking the leaked oil back up into a containment unit on board the ship using the (Probe & Drogue Fuel System). Hence think of the leak from the riser as the fueling jet and the (ROV) as the other jet and the ship above now becomes the containment area. There is only one problem that needs to be re-solved how to fit the (PDFuel system onto the riser opening. If memory serves me well I believe that the (Probe & Drogue System) has a vacuum like docking mechanism or umbrella type floater cup that once connected clamps into place using automated suction and of course some manual controller interaction as well. But on the other end meaning the riser this could be a problem because it will not have the other part of this particular system attached to its opening but this is something I am sure could be remedied by skill full engineering. Now if this device can handle fuel pumping at high speeds and high altitudes then why not use it for deep underwater problems such as this. I believe with this idea it would allow the time needed to drill and cap off the other (BOP) which would take about 2-3 months and can be achieved with less risk and a more precise outcome. This would reduce the risk factors of creating a possible bigger problem if something were to go wrong and would at best stop the huge flow of oil that is presently leaking. The ROV would have to be anchored down to keep it in place perhaps to a part of the original (BOP) or ocean floor and a very flexible long boom tubing would have to be fitted onto the (ROV) attached off the side of the original (Probe & Drogue Fuel System) thus extending back up to the ship. I have looked and studied the area of concern and understand there are problems that can be quite dangerous while working at such depths. But I strongly believe this idea if implemented precisely could work. The tools are already available they just need to be engineered and constructed too meet this type of application. This idea of cutting and trying to recap the riser opening I feel is too risky and if it were too fail you could end up with a much larger problem on your hands and 3 months of this kind of new opening would be unimaginable too how much damage has already been caused. The idea too keep in mind at this point in time is not to try and stop the leak but more over contain it until you can safely drill and cap off the other (BOP) in 2-3 months. This is in my opinion the best course of action at this late time and is a much more effective and safer way to solve this matter and possibly avert a far more damaging scenario in the long run. If this plan were implemented and worked as mentioned it could be a possible fallback in preventing or at best being able to deal with any future incidents such as this.

Thank you

From a free thinker and amateur inventor on how to make use of pre-existing applications:
Carmen Veglia May 30, 2010


Dear Alternative Response
 
I know there has been a world wide response on how to cap the leak and many great ideas have been submitted. But is it possible to take a heavy duty canvas lined on the inside with a thick durable rubber like what they use on some boats coast guard boats) and build one to spec of the pipe. This inflatable canvas tube should be as long as possible and have a quick disconnect on the end. I know there is allot of pressure at this depth and inflating might be impossible. So putting a check valve on the pipe connected to the canvas tube may help pump the air into the device. If that is impossible the canvas tube could also be filled with drilling mud until the canvas tube has been expanded to its maximum potential. If you are concerned that the pressure of the oil would push it out then some type of spur or gripping device could be built into one end. This idea is simple and could be made very quickly do to the fact the technology is already been made.    
   
Thanks, Josh Brewer
josh.brewer85@yahoo.com
05-30-10
This design approach results in a gasket outer pipe with a valve..
The gasket is tapered and attached to the existing riser with transverse pins (double headed bolts) that have a protruding head similar to a double headed nail..
The gasket can be made in sections which will avoid any problems due to existing oil flow..
The double headed pins are used to fasten the new flared pipe/valve assembly to the existing riser.
 
Once the double headed pins are in place, they can be used to align the flared pipe/valve assembly with the riser
with cables etc.
This solution results in having the well shaft plugged at the oil supply at the beginning of the shaft..
 
It uses the same design approach as a FOLEY CATHETER (medical device)..
 
After insertion all the way to the beginning of the shaft the end is inflated hydraulically.
THE HYDRAULIC PUMP CAN BE EMBEDDED IN LOWEST PART ( THE AMBIENT RELATIVE PRESSURE IS MINIMAL )..
THIS SOLUTION RESULTS IN THE RISER BEING PLUGGED INTERNALLY...
 
It works in a similar fashion that a soda can is crushed by one stomping on it.
 
The can-like plug is inserted in the riser...attached to the far end of the can is a cable that
runs internally through the can and out the near end.. pins would be inserted through the riser which would prevent the can from being pulled out of the riser when the cable is tensioned..
This would result in the can/like plug expanding inside the existing riser..
Ianrichter@aol.com
Cut the "kinked" pipe off, insert a smaller gauge of drill bit until oil has stopped or as limited as possible.  A step further would be to put a rubber condom on the drill bit and insert it straight in without spinning.

 
Paul Koniuck
Portfolio Strategies Corp
(204) 229-4328
portfoliopaul@mts.net

Idea 1

Large collapsed balloons that fill with oil after being placed over oil leak and anchored to the ocean floor until full. Once full, they would be released and another balloon would be put in place. The oil rises to the top of the balloon while water is pushed out below (oil being heavier than water). Pressure relieve tubes would be on the top that would float to surface allowing gas to be released into the air above the surface. Weighted at the bottom, these balloons could be moved to an area where the oil could be siphoned out into tankers and then reused. The balloon material would contain the oil from the surrounding ocean water.

Idea 2

A large tube (1-300’ wide) made with an oil containing material that would be neutrally buoyant with rings to keep form and positioned using GPS guidance devices. The tube would extent from near the ocean floor to slightly below the surface allowing water to be pushed out near the surface and below. Once the water has been pushed out, additional air buoyancy would be added to keep at surface and from leaking over the top. Caps could be added on the top and bottom to better contain the oil. When the tube is full, a new tube would be put in place while the old tube is moved and siphoned out. Tubes could then be recycled back in action.

Let me know what you think.
Duncan W. Lee
CEO
Engineered Products Co. and PDU Cables Inc.
5401 Smetana Dr.
Minnetonka, MN 55343
www.engproducts.com
www.pducables.com
dlee@engproducts.com
952-215-5077


To Whom it May Concern:

Below is a simple technology that I believe is a viable solution for the oil spill. I also attach a diagram of the apparatus I created.

This is a simple technology consisting of a hollow pole manufactured from steel. One end of the pole is fabricated into an aerodynamic spear opening with two steel flaps. The steel pole is lined with a rubber tube with a balloon shaped end. Inside the rubber tube is an aluminum rod with umbrella like prongs at the end of the balloon reservoir. The steel pole is attached to a hydraulic system from the ship or robotic submarine and is lowered and inserted into the oil well at the broken opening. The steel pole is inserted into the opening of the oil well approximately 50 meters deep. From the ship or the robotic submarine, the hollow steel pole is filled with a mixture of cement substance as well as plastic foam similar or stronger to that used as insulation in a building structure. The mixed substance flows through the steel pole and is ejected into the head of the rubber balloon (heavy duty rubber that tires are made from or stronger). Once filled the umbrella like prongs spread open and assist to hold the balloon shape and block the sides of the oil well so that the oil spill is trapped and cannot leak. The prongs are attached to the balloon inside by rubber tips so that the prongs do not break the rubber balloon. The balloon also forces the spear shaped end of the steel pole to open the hinges and hold the balloon securely in place. The balloon is filled with cement and plastic foam substance and expands to cover the oil well hole and traps the oil from leaking beyond the hinged flaps. The hinged flaps stay in place, trap the oil from spilling out. The balloon filled with the cement/plastic foam substance will maintain the oil spill long enough for major repairs to be made to the outside of the oil well where the explosion occurred. The steel rod can be removed in the future if necessary.

Materials Required:

1-Outer Hollow steel pole with movable steel hatch

2-Inner hollow aluminum rob lined with heavy duty rubber and rubber balloon attachment; aluminum umbrella like prongs fabricated inside the hollow rubber balloon

3- Inner aluminum rod in end attached to hydraulic system which pushes hollow aluminum rod with balloon attached forward. 

4-Rubber balloon manufactured from strong rubber used for trucks, heavy machinery

5-Concrete cement and foam which can be turn to solid matter within seconds

Thank  you for your consideration,

Ray Kalhory

Toronto ON Canada L4L 8Y6

Tel: 416-419-2534


Thank you for taking my submission.
Daniel Garcia
621 Screen Printing
2300 N.St Marys
San Antonio, TX 78212
210-733-5514
print621@yahoo.com
www.print621.com 
visit our catalog @
www.forsportswear.com


Built a Box with hinged lids so they will stay open on the way down to the sea floor.  Make the middle section solid with a hose connected to the middle to pump out the water on the way down.
 
Once the box reaches the sea floor, secure the lids and continue pumping the water. The pump should create a vacuum as to seal the hinge doors and the box to the sea floor so that everything may be sucked out underneath.  Relief holes may be drilled at a later time to make it possible to reuse the well.
 
Thank You
Eddie Bullins
9648 West Market Street
Kernersville, NC 27284
336-423-6886


Re: Icing that blocked the first cap attempt.
I liked the creative idea of injecting water into the well bore.
Maybe fresh water would be even better ? I think this is worth a look by BP.
I then thought, Could the icing be due to the pressure drop of gas escaping
the casing or the drill shaft? Rather than just low temp and ambient
pressure? Like refrigeration principles and rapidly expanding gas?

"Top Kill" seems to have failed because of too much pressure difference
between the BOP and -5,000' Sea bottom pressure?

Someone should think of how to use the icing to advantage. There must be a
way that the icing can be used to separate the methane gas from the oil
stream. I'll be thinking how that might look.

Keep thinking .........

Jim Elliot

Del Mar Properties
Broker/Coastside
Realtor/Inventor/Sailor/Contractor/Designer/Carpenter/Artist/Musician/Potter
/Thinker:
(H) 650-726-0473 
(c) 650-743-4086 
(o) 650-712-6800

www.cdelmarrealestate.com
DRE Lic# 01161912 / CSLB Lic# 328726


Hello! My name is Aaron Ham from Odessa,TX. One way to cleanup the oil is using the material properties of water and oil to our advantage. For example, the freezing point of oil is different to the freezing point of water. Therefore, we could theoretically freeze one of the liquids and remove or separate the other one. aaronyham@gmail.com


This idea was submitted by me almost 3 weeks ago, during the phase where they were still trying to get it done by their 'containment dome'.
 
Anyhow, the answer I received from them, was very short and they simply said it was not possible, I'll forward this email to you. And now they're talking about something similar, although I don't know how they're going to cut/saw the riser. I proposed -As you can learn in the PDF-file- to do this by abrasive water-jet cutting.
 
As addition to this PDF-file, I would propose to house all the equipment you’ll need, such as a direct drive pump (for creating high pressure the efficient way), a hopper (for the abrasive additive), a inlet-filter (for the water), and the power generator inside one compact container, to be lowered by another robot or crane. The flow of high-pressurized water will flow from this unit tubed to jeweled nozzle, mounted on the ROV's robotic jaw. (Probably best to mount the hopper as close as possible at the nozzle, so therefore somewhere on/in the ROV).
 
--> Also, if possible, I would like to propose to simply tap a new pipe into the length of the riser that's left over, after the cutting process, and standing vertical, or else directly into the BOP. This is to be done by making use of a (certain) length of pipe with a smaller diameter/radius than the part that's left over. The bottom end of this piece of pipe will need an external male thread to tap and cut a female thread into what's left over of the riser. This 'tapping-pipe' will require a thicker wall and a higher hardness than the material of the riser (or BOP). The top end of this tapping-pipe will require a flange. Making it possible to (pre)mount a new riser, or preferably mount another BOP in between the failed BOP and the new riser.
 
All by all this piece of tapping pipe doesn't have to be that long.
 
Could you post my suggestions as described in the PDF-file and the supplement in this email on your dedicated website? In order to get this out, maybe it will spin-off other ideas and suggestions. I hope so.
 
Thanks and regards,


 

 

 
 

  Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
 

Back to Top

 

www.AlternativeResponseTechnology.com  All rights reserved - 2010  

 

Oil Worker Jobs I Oil Spill Cleanup Jobs I AlternativeResponseTechnology